What to ask when applying for a PhD position

BG
Want to know more?  Contact for advice.
Contact
Karin van Vuuren
Research Affairs
researchaffairs@hetpnn.nl

What to ask when applying for a PhD position

A checklist to get a clear idea of the PhD position you are interviewing for. 

A PhD takes four years or more and shapes a large part of your career and wellbeing. An interview is not only your chance to show what you can do, but also to judge whether the position and organisation fits you. Use the questions below as a checklist. Each one comes with a short explanation of why it matters. Select what matters most to you. 

Before asking these questions during the interviews, it is helpful to formulate your own answers and wishes as well. This helps voicing your needs and gives a well-prepared impression. 

1. Supervision

  • Who will supervise me day to day and who will be my promotor? Your supervisor shapes most of your experience. Know who the promoter and the daily supervisor are, and what each one's role is. Check out our page on Supervision.
  • What are the supervisor's strengths and pitfalls? Every supervisor has a style (hands-on or distant, quick or slow with feedback). An honest answer shows whether that style suits you and whether they reflect on their own supervision. Make sure that you know what you need in terms of supervision style. 
  • How often will you be having meetings with your supervisor, and what does supervision look like? Clear expectations on contact moments, feedback turnaround and independence prevent frustration later.
  • How many PhD candidates does this person supervise at once? A full agenda means less time for you. However, working together with other PhD candidates can also be beneficial. How often is the supervisor at the university?
  • Can I talk one-on-one with a PhD candidate (or recent graduate) from the group? They will tell you what the people at the interview table do not always say. Ask for a one-on-one meeting with other PhDs in the department. A group that hesitates is informative in itself.

2. Project, content and freedom

  • How much freedom is there in the design and topic of my PhD? Some projects are fully fixed, others leave room for your own direction. Know what you are getting and whether it suits you.
  • Are there midterm goals or deliverables, and how do they limit my freedom? Project deliverables (for example towards a funder or partner) can steer your research or take up time that does not go directly into your thesis.
  • Is the required research equipment, data management plan, ethical clearance, software or field access available? Waiting times, shared equipment or missing licences can seriously delay your planning. Also ask who arranges access to a certain field (social sciences) or whether you have to build the network on your own. Decide what suits you. 
  • What are the publication expectations and how does authorship work? This tells you what is expected of you, whether this is feasible to you, and whether you can share authorship and still include it in your dissertation. 
  • Will I be working together with other PhDs or postdocs on this project? Is it interdisciplinary? This tells you whether you will be doing soloistic or team work, whether joint papers might be written, whether you’re allowed to count these papers as part of your dissertation. Or whether you will be bridging different research fields. 
  • Is it possible to include other outputs into your dissertation? Are you interested in engaging with a policy field, citizens, or industry and do you also want to include other forms of output in your thesis? This is the time to ask whether the team is up for that. For more information about other forms of research output: PhD of the Future - guide

3. External partners and collaboration

  • Are external partners involved (industry, government, NGOs)? How is the collaboration shaped? Partners can offer data, network and application, but may also set demands on direction, pace and confidentiality.
  • Are there agreements on publication, intellectual property and confidentiality? Restrictions on publishing can affect your thesis and your later career.
  • Is there room for an internship or a stay at another university or organisation? A placement or research stay broadens your network and skills. Check whether it is planned, funded and supported by the group.

4. Funding and resources

  • Is the full PhD trajectory funded (contract, duration, possible extension)? Funding that runs out halfway is a major risk. Also ask what happens in case of delay, for example due to illness or leave.
  • Is there a budget for conferences, courses and travel? Visibility and networking are essential for your career. Know whether a budget is available and whether there is a per-person limit.
  • Are costs for publications (open access), materials, events or participant inclusion covered? Unexpected costs can slow down your research if there is no budget for them.

5. Policy and organisation

  • How is PhD policy arranged at department and faculty level (graduate school, supervision plan, progress meetings), are PhDs included in policy-making and staff meetings? Formal structure gives you something to hold on to when things go wrong and makes progress measurable.
  • What obligations are there besides research (teaching duties, course credits, administration)? Teaching and other tasks take time, but could also be something you love to do. If the latter is the case, is it possible to obtain a University Teaching Qualification (UTQ)?
  • How is career guidance organized and are next steps supported? A PhD is also a stepping stone. Look at where former PhD students end up and whether the group helps with that.

6. Culture and work-life balance

  • What does a normal working week look like, and what is expected regarding working hours and availability? Expectations about evening and weekend work differ strongly per group. A clear answer prevents disappointment later.
  • What is the atmosphere in the group, and how often are there shared moments? A PhD can be lonely. An open, supportive group makes a big difference to your wellbeing and motivation.
  • How are leave, illness, caregiving handled? The answer shows how the group treats you as a person, not only as a researcher.
  • How often am I expected to be present at the faculty? Can I work from home?
  • Is it possible to work part-time and will my contract be extended? You might prefer to work part-time. If you have a contract for 4 days a week your contract should be extended accordingly. 

Tips for the interview

  • Ask neutrally and with curiosity. The goal is a good fit, not an accusation.
  • Compare the answers of the supervisor and the PhD candidates. Big differences are informative.
  • Ask for agreements to be put in writing, especially on funding, freedom and collaboration. If you don’t feel comfortable asking for these agreements in writing during the hiring process, you can, when hired, revisit some of the questions in the above list during the start of your PhD trajectory and include them in your Training and Supervision plan. 
  • Not having a perfect answer to everything is normal. Pay most attention to openness and how people handle difficult questions

Are you currently experiencing issues during your PhD that you need help with?

Most institutions have a number of contact points for help. This compass is designed to help you find the right support.

In the drop-down menu you can select the institution that you are doing your PhD at. Then the roadmap will show you available contact points. In most cases it makes sense to start by considering contact points in your immediate work environment first and then progress to higher levels (like institutional or national).

At the bottom of the page you can find some examples of problems you can run into and a list of descriptions of each contact point.

Your first contact points

Colleagues: Sometimes it can already help to talk with your colleagues about the issue you are experiencing. This will help you judge the severity of it and can provide you with allies in taking further action.‍

Daily supervisor*: Naturally, your daily supervisor is the first contact point for all issues. They can help you determine the next steps. Of course, you may not feel comfortable discussing everything with your supervisor, or maybe your daily supervisor is involved in the issue. In these cases have a look at the other available contact points.

‍Promotor or Co-Supervisor*: Especially, in cases of issues with your daily supervisor, consider reaching out to your promotor or another member on the supervision team and ask for a one-on-one meeting. Maybe they can (temporarily) step-up and help you resolve the issue.If you have a conflict with your supervisor(s), you can also have a look at the PNN PhD supervisor conflict roadmap.

*Note that your annual review talk with your supervisory team is a good opportunity to address issues or suggestions for improvement.

Institutional Level

Faculty / Department / Graduate School Level

Institutional Level

Faculty / Department / Graduate School Level

National contact points

Labor unions: Organizations representing the interests of academic staff, offering support on employment-related matters, rights, and fair treatment.

‍NWO Scientific Integrity Desk: A specialized desk addressing scientific integrity concerns in projects related to or funded by the Dutch Research Council (NWO).

‍Netherlands Board of Research Integrity (LOWI): An independent body handling complaints related to scientific integrity, providing a platform for fair investigation. If you feel like the local scientific integrity committee at your institution did not handle a case correctly, the LOWI can be the next contact point.

‍Making a police report: In cases involving a criminal offense, please consider contacting local law enforcement to report incidents and seek assistance.

Examples

Unsure what kind of problems you can reach out for? You can take a look at some examples here but remember that no matter how big or small you feel your problem is, you can always reach out for help.
Workload and Time Management
Personal Well-being
Supervision and Mentorship
Workplace Environment
Career and Future Concerns

Descriptions

Here are some descriptions of each contact point:
Faculty PhD counil
Graduate School
Faculty Dean
PhD Mentor at faculty/department level
PhD organization
Company doctor
PhD Psychologist / Counsellor
HR advisor
Scientific Integrity advisor / committe
Confidential advisor
Share this post